CITIES FOR CLIMATE PROTECTION
An International Campaign to Reduce Urban Emissions of Greenhouse Gases
International Council for Local Environmental Initiatives (ICLEI)
Jeb Brugmann, Secretary General
Philip Jessup, Director, The Urban CO2 Reduction Project
February 15, 1993
CONTENTS
Introduction
Encouragement of National Campaigns
Program Services to ICLEI Members
- Green Fleets
- Energy Buildings
- Energy Partners
The Framework Convention: Liaison with the UN
Administration of the Campaign
Appendix A - Municipal Leaders' Declaration on Climate Change and the Urban Environment
Urban emissions of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases contribute a significant portion of the world's total at atmospheric loading of these gases. Over 50 percent of the world's population now lives in urban areas, and urbanization is continuing apace especially in developing countries. The heating and cooling of urban buildings, consumption of electricity by local industries and businesses, and the transport of people and goods to, from, and within urban centers all are energy-intensive activities that produce greenhouse gases and other noxious emissions that affect the quality of life in urban centers.
Because urban centers are major sources of greenhouse gases, municipalities have an important role to play in reducing emissions of these gases. Indeed, a good deal of evidence has accumulated that urban form -- the density, mixture, and physical layout of residential and commercial neighborhoods -- profoundly influences local energy intensity, the amount of energy each person on average consumes annually. Urban form is not just the chance result of history and geography, but often reflects deliberate municipal policy over time to shape the character of the city, using local land use planning and infrastructure investment powers.
In June 1991. the Urban CO2 Reduction Project convened 14 municipalities in the United States, Canada, Europe, and Turkey in a two-year initiative to develop comprehensive local strategies to reduce emissions of greenhouse gases, especially CO2. Through a series of six one-week policy workshops, technical consultation, and research drawing on the data gathered by each municipality, the Project has sought to develop a generic framework for municipal energy policy that local governments generally may use to implement locally to develop policies to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Phase I of the Project will conclude in June, 1993, as the 14 municipalities submit their "local action plans" to their governing councils for consideration and approval.
At the Municipal Leaders' Summit on Climate Change and the Urban Environment, held at the United Nations in January, 1993 and co-sponsored by ICLEI and UNEP, ICLEI announced Phase II of the Project, and international campaign -- Cities for Climate Protection -- to strengthen local governments' ability to develop and implement municipal energy policies that reduce local emissions of greenhouse gases. The campaign is scheduled to begin during the summer/fall, 1993, subject to the availability of new financial resources. The primary goals of the Cities for Climate Protection Campaign are:
ICLEI plans to undertake a de-centralized campaign that seeks to generate enthusiasm and commitment among national and sub-national municipal associations worldwide. The first step was involving the following national and regional associations as co-sponsors of the aforementioned Summit:
Representatives of these associations as well as other municipal leaders attending the Summit reviewed a draft Municipal Leaders' Declaration on Climate Change prepared by ICLEI. As a result of their suggestions, a final Declaration was prepared. This generic document will serve as a template for National Declarations, which will be prepared by national and sub-national associations in consultation with their members. Hence, any municipal government will be able to join Cities for Climate Protection by becoming a formal signatory to a National Municipal Leaders' Declaration on Climate Change. Alternatively, municipal governments may join the campaign by signing ICLEI's generic Declaration if a National Declaration is unavailable.
The "world campaign" will initially work closely with the municipal associations that attended the Summit and with whom ICLEI already has close relations, such as the National League of Cities in the US. Through this de-centralized process of deliberation, consultation, and local advocacy, ICLEI hopes to enlist 100 municipalities worldwide by 1995 that account for one billion tonnes of global CO2 emissions. By joining the Campaign each municipality pledges to:
ICLEI will administer and coordinate the Campaign and provide the following services -- subject to financial resources -- to all Campaign Members (regardless of whether they are ICLEI members or not). ICLEI will:
In addition to the newsletter, Campaign members will receive several publications that provide a generic framework for analysis and decisionmaking. These will include: Saving the Climate, Saving the Cities: A Municipal Agenda (published); Baseline Energy Use and Emissions Manual, a step-by-step technical guide that assists the analyst in the preparation of municipal energy scenarios (research in progress); Inventory of Municipal Energy Measures that characterizes a variety of key technologies and retrofit measures to reduce local fossil energy use (research in progress); and a Municipal Too Kit of Innovative Financing of energy efficiency programs (research completed, final editing and publication in progress).
To be effective these policies should set a leadership example and be expandable to other sectors. Such policies include a range of measures including:
Denver originally developed the Green Fleets initiative with US EPA support through the ICLEI Urban CO2 Reduction Project. ICLEI is now seeking to adapt this approach as a wider initiative.
Municipalities that join the Green Fleets initiative will pledge to reduce energy use and CO2 emissions from their employees' travel -- both commuting travel and on-the-job travel -- by 20 percent over a 10-year period. After outside financial support is secured, ICLEI will refine and disseminate an analytical framework for estimating vehicle fleet emissions and employee travel that is being developed by Denver, develop a model Green Fleets ordinance, monitor the progress of municipalities that have joined the initiative, and conduct and disseminate case studies of successful local projects.
Working with the Urban Consortium in Washington DC, ICLEI will seek to develop a strategic procurement initiative in North America for fuel efficient automobiles, in collaboration with Public Technology, Inc. in Washington DC, once a "critical mass" of municipalities in North America have adopted new procurement policies under Green Fleets.
While Green Fleets will focus initially on the development of policies for reducing energy use from municipalities' own vehicle fleets and employee travel, ICLEI is also seeking to conduct an intensive collaborative research effort with five to10 municipalities in the United States to identify broader transportation policies that aim to expand the Green Fleets goals and methodologies to other transportation sectors, especially policies that aim to reduce overall demand for personal mobility. This effort will seek to pioneer new analytical techniques for better understanding the determinants of local transportation energy use, such as the underlying relationship between land use and travel demand. It will also develop model trip reduction ordinances and transit oriented development guidelines that can be implemented locally. Once the two-year research project is concluded, Green Fleets will be broadened to include wider dissemination of these new municipal tools and practices.
ICLEI hopes to begin an initial six-month research and planning phase for Green Fleets by June, 1993. If further funding becomes available, full start-up may be possible by January, 1994.
Municipalities have already gained a good deal of experience in retrofitting their own building stock with energy efficiency and renewable measures -- Leicester, Glasgow, Saarbrücken, and Phoenix are examples -- that this initiative could draw on, and Toronto is helping to pioneer innovative new financing methods.
Municipalities that join the Energy Buildings initiative will pledge to reduce energy use and CO2 emissions in their buildings and facilities by 20 percent over a 10-year period. Strategies that municipalities can pursue include:
ICLEI is presently conducting research that when published will assist municipalities that join this initiative. Reports that are planned include an Inventory of Municipal Energy Measures that will characterize a variety of key technologies and retrofit measures to reduce local fossil energy use and a Municipal Tool Kit of Innovative Financing that outlines innovative ways to finance energy efficiency measures.
Energy Buildings will initially conduct two collaborative research efforts aimed at developing new methodologies for analyzing energy use in municipally owned buildings and for financing energy efficiency retrofits in these buildings. With funding from the Ontario Ministry of Energy (Canada) and The Joyce and Milwaukee, Chicago , Saint Paul, and Minneapolis in the United States over a period of two years in the Ontario Municipal Energy Collaborative and the Great Lakes Municipal Energy Collaborative.
A primary goal of the two collaboratives is to encourage the municipalities to develop comprehensive energy efficiency retrofit plans for their buildings and facilities, and to aggregate such municipal energy service demand in such a way as to attract major third-party financing from banks, insurance companies, and capital investment firms. The project will produce model municipal energy policies that are more widely applicable to other municipalities in the Cities for Climate Protection Campaign.With funding now secure, start-up of this initiative is planned for spring, 1993.
Participants would be supported to provide assistance to other municipalities directly through their own channels, such as "sister city" relationships. ICLEI would provide training and briefings to the Consultants on the application of energy efficiency measures in different developmental and regional contexts. In effect, ICLEI would work to develop a cadre of municipal energy consultants who can professionally assist their municipal counterparts abroad. Once Energy Partners Consulting is fully established, ICLEI would help market municipal expertise, with a portion of the fees from contracts through ICLEI's brokerage to be contributed to the Fund (see below).
As the first meeting of the Conference of Parties approaches in late 1994 or early 1995, ICLEI will seek to organize and sponsor the 2nd World Municipal Leaders' Summit on Climate Change and the Urban Environment, to be held in tandem with the UN meeting. At the 2nd Summit municipal leaders will present reports on their efforts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, and they will develop an agenda to present to national governments and international agencies participating in the first Conference of Parties meeting.
INTRODUCTION
ENCOURAGEMENT OF NATIONAL CAMPAIGNS
Associazione Nazionale dei Comuni Italiani
Association of Finnish Cities
Convention of Scottish Local Authorities
Deutscher Städtetag
Federation of Canadian Municipalities
International Union of Local Authorities (IULA)
IULA Section for the Eastern Mediterranean and Middle East Region
Local Government International Bureau (UK)
National League of Cities (US)
Organization of Islamic Capitals and Cities
Public Technology Incorporated (US)
United States Conference of Mayors
Western Australian Municipal Association
Municipalities that have become signatories to a Declaration who are also Members of ICLEI will be eligible to participate in specific ICLEI services that will be offered as funding permits. These include three initiatives that are described below: Green Fleets, Energy Buildings, and Energy Partners.
PROGRAM SERVICES TO ICLEI MEMBERSGreen Fleets
The adoption of policies that reduce the transportation energy used by municipal employees as they commute to work and perform their jobs are among the initiatives that municipalities can first undertake to reduce CO2 emissions.
Such initiatives have multiple benefits. They can save the municipality money, reduce automobile emissions that contribute to poor local air quality, as well as show leadership. When local vehicle procurement can be strategically pooled with that of other municipalities, local governments can also influence manufactures to produce lower polluting vehicles.
Energy Buildings
The potential retrofit of municipally owned buildings and facilities offers a significant opportunity for reducing energy use and CO2 emissions, cutting municipal energy bills, and stimulating job creation in the local community. In some countries, significant private capital is available to finance such retrofits, usually through private energy service companies, thereby reducing the need for public investment.
Energy Partners
This initiative, jointly conceived by the City of Amsterdam and ICLEI, would exchange energy management expertise among municipalities in the developed nations with those in developing nations and the emerging economies. Energy Partners, currently in an early planning phase, could also be used to establish pilot "joint implementation" (see Article 1 of the draft Declaration, Appendix A) projects among municipalities that want to "trade" CO2 emissions for the purpose of facilitating cost effective solutions to meet local and national CO2 reduction targets. Two specific sources of assistance will be explored:
The development of Energy Partners requires further forward planning and consultation among the candidate municipalities, international development agencies, national governments, and ICLEI. During the coming year, ICLEI will initially seek to identify one to three municipalities in the developing world and/or emerging economies that could serve as pilot communities in Energy Partners, while contributing further discussions with the appropriate agencies regarding development of initial projects. Consideration will be given particularly to partnerships that aim to develop major new infrastructure investments in the pilot communities that, while providing valuable energy services to the community, reduce energy use and CO2 emissions as well. Start-up of the initiative is planned for the second year of the Cities for Climate Protection Campaign.
The United Nations has asked ICLEI to participate in meetings of the Framework Convention on Climate Change as a non-governmental organization. The Cities for Climate Protection Campaign, therefore, will participate as an observer in these proceedings, and it will seek to represent the collective views of municipalities in future deliberations.
THE FRAMEWORK CONVENTION: LIAISON WITH THE UN

